'I'm Fine' — But Are You Really?

Remembering not to be judgemental, understanding tone and what we say matters adds more to showing actual care to someone and will be felt.

By Alinafe Wilson •
'I'm Fine' — But Are You Really?

“I'm fine", a quick and almost reflexive answer to any inquiry about how we are. We learn, slowly and quietly, the way we learn greetings, table manners and how we learn to treat the people around us, whether we know how they are doing truly or not. We are not to treat them based on our own assumptions or what we heard about them, but through active listening and many other things, learn what actually might be the issue.

The first place we often learn how to share anything is at home. A small child cries, and the response teaches you what the right thing to do is. If a parent comforts the child, the child learns that feelings are safe to show. If the parent says "stop crying" or "be strong," the child learns that feelings are a problem to hide. Most parents mean well. They were taught the same way, by their own parents, who were taught by theirs. In this way, silence passes down the generations like a family recipe.

We sometimes find ourselves in familiar situations in the company of unfamiliar people or in unfamiliar situations without anyone familiar around to coddle us when we find something to be sad about. Better yet, when what we did not want to happen happens. In those moments, what we have known to do whenever we feel like that comes out instinctively; it has become who we are. You wonder why your brother reacted a certain way to what another sibling said to him, quick to judge even when you might have reacted the same, given that it was you that those things were said to. While you both might not know any better, being empathetic towards one another is the key to opening the channel to reciprocation with the people around you.

Popular media has a hand in shaping the narratives and stereotypes around personality that most find themselves aspiring to be. Which doesn’t do us any favours: be strong, they say, and you can do it on your own, they say. The reality is that suppressing what we feel only makes it worse. Sharing that bit, which we think might not be worth it, is doing a lot for us and connecting us to people we share with.

Any sort of safe space for our vulnerability becomes all we know and a key to the daily goings-on of our lives. A friend who listens while we share what made us angry this morning. The scones your mother bakes you whenever she wants to know what's happening in your life. The key is community, just how much we are because of the people we share our lives with.

Then comes shame, which is the feeling that makes people hide what they feel. Many people are afraid of being seen as weak, dramatic or “mad.” A Zambian study of family caregivers in Lusaka, led by Frank Sichimba of the University of Zambia, I believe, found that people’s beliefs about mental illness strongly shaped how they responded. The study’s themes included beliefs about what causes mental illness, experiences of social support and neglect, and realising the need for professional help. Another summary of the research notes that these beliefs affected not only help-seeking but also how people related to their families. When a person fears that their feelings will change how others see them, not sharing feels safer.

With time, inwardly the tension builds up. We avoid being a burden to others even when they haven't told us we are.  We think we are our problems and connect them to the bigger issues in our life, and the spiral goes on.

We should be careful not to swing too far. Not every quiet person is unwell. Some people enjoy the quiet, and some simply enjoy calm. Treating every reserved person as a patient would be another harmful lesson. The better habit is to notice change: a friend who sleeps badly, loses interest in things they love, withdraws, or drinks more than before. Then ask gently, listen without rushing to fix, and keep what you hear private. If someone talks about ending their life, ask directly and stay with them. Asking does not plant the idea. It shows you care.

Help is everywhere it is important to understand that. Chainama Hills College Hospital in Lusaka is the main national referral centre for psychiatric care. A published Lusaka directory also lists mental health units at Chilenje and Kanyama first-level hospitals, and the Psychology Association of Zambia. For a first step by phone, Lifeline Zambia, on 933, is a helpline for adults, and Childline, on 116, is for children, with counsellors available by phone, WhatsApp or Facebook around the clock. The 990 Talkline is a toll-free helpline on Airtel, MTN and Zamtel. If you have no one around you feel safe to talk to, these helplines are here to comfort you. And Government facilities are usually the most affordable place to begin. Services remain limited, and an older report by the Mental Disability Advocacy Centre found that mental health care was nearly non-existent at the primary healthcare level and concentrated in a handful of hospitals. Things may have improved since, but it reminds us why friends and families matter so much.

Remembering not to be judgemental, understanding tone and what we say matters adds more to showing actual care to someone and will be felt. We can learn to say something true. It begins with one honest answer, and one person willing to hear it.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Stay informed. Stay inspired.

Type to search or try advanced search
Type to search or try advanced search